News

Friends in Three Countries Gather to Discuss Betsy’s Wedding 

Once per season, we offer a midday Saturday book discussion to make it easier for our outside-the-U.S. friends and members to attend, and it’s always quite thrilling to welcome folks in Canada, England, France, Germany, Portugal, and Russia. For these smaller discussions, we always have participants introduce themselves, and today each shared a favorite moment from this very romantic book. The runaway winner was the resolution of the Aunt Ruth conflict – people loved seeing how Betsy and Joe work through this struggle and come to a happy solution. As one person noted, “Betsy not only makes the best of this situation, she also truly embraces it and comes to love Aunt Ruth dearly.”

And this was a nice segue to something I (Jennifer D-K) wanted to discuss today: I think that Wedding is the most different in tone from the other books in the series because the conflicts are so very ADULT. Can we afford to buy a house? Why aren’t we getting pregnant? Is Tib in a bad relationship, and how should we intervene? Will the U.S. go to war, will all our boys come home?

Our discussion flew fast and furious for two hours, and we all had a simply delightful time. Below are some Gaston-approved high points.

Betsy’s Engagement, Such As It Is

Did you know? The working title of this book was Mrs. Betsy. Which title do you prefer?

Sonja (in Germany!): Mrs. Betsy sounds like a book of household tips. Betsy’s Wedding as the last book in a series about a growing-up girl is a better title.

Diane: So much of this book is about friendship, and Mrs. Betsy is a more limiting title.

The pace of the engagement is breathless. Is this because we’ve waited long enough? Are you disappointed at all by the speed with which everything occurs?

Rita: They’ve known each other for YEARS. Enough already!

Kathleen: When I read it at age 12-ish, I wanted them to wait and do all the wedding rituals, but as an adult I love it.

Diane: From a real-life point of view, I think it’s terrible – they haven’t seen each other for a long time. From a literary point of view, I love it. It’s so romantic!

Theresa: I agree. They’ve known each other for a long time, but they haven’t known each other as adults for a long time.

Sonja: But nothing in Betsy’s life has prepared her to deal with Joe’s depression, and I’m not sure that spending more time engaged would have changed that.

Maddi: I found the long wait to get to the Rays’ while Joe looked for a job so stressful. You’ll find a job! Just get home already!

Jen: For sure. But what we know about Joe Willard is that he is proud. And this proud boy does not want to come home to his prospective in-laws without a job!

How do you suppose Teddy Roosevelt came up in Joe and Bob Ray’s wedding talk??

Rita: Mr. Ray would have been asking Joe about his work, and Joe recently interviewed Teddy, Bob Ray’s hero.

Marlena: “[Mr. Ray’s] voice warmed with interest. ‘Joe interviewed Teddy just a short time ago. He’s been giving me all Teddy’s views. Teddy thinks just as I do, and just as Joe does, that this is an assault on civilization.’”

[Note: BT trivia expert Jen D-K had utterly forgotten this fact 🤣]

Tacy

Many have noted how much they miss Tacy in the high school books. I think she is a strong character in this one and such an important mentor to Betsy. What do you think?

Kristen (in England!): Company dinner!

Jen: Yes! Game changer for so many of us!

Susan: In the other books, Tacy is more of a sidekick – but in this one, she has advanced beyond where Betsy is. I appreciate her maturity and grace in this book and how her strengths – that were always there – are really highlighted in this book.

Maddi: I love when Tacy tells Betsy not to say baby Kelly is handsome, “for I know better,” and then she snuggles him “protectively”! One more glimpse into the beautiful person Tacy is/was in Betsy’s/Maud’s life. But I would have liked a few more scenes with Tacy and Harry in the book – I loved meeting the character of Harry in Betsy and Joe.

Sonja: It happens quite often in real life that the first one who has a baby makes friends with other new parents and may spend less time with the first friend group or be less included. I think it’s beautiful that Tacy is still part of the group even after she has children.

Susan: I love the sense of community in this book and how all the friends are there for one another.

Diane: A series that started with their relationship needs to end with Tacy being more present than she was in the high school books

Tib

Something that hit me on this read: The first book and the last book in this series end with a focus on Tib. What do you make of that?

Kathleen: Tib is the bookend!

Sonja: I would have loved to read Tib’s own book!

Jen: It is the Betsy-Tacy series, but Tib is so, so important to Betsy as well. As are all the friends who get their own books . . . and her other bestie, Cab, who gets a great role in the last few books, especially Emily!

Tib really comes into her own in this book. We see shades of her independence in high school, but did you predict this as her post-high school future?

Paula: Tib is living the dream! She is just so cool.

Amaree: I related a lot to single Tib. My friends got married off, and I was the odd one out in their conversations . . . but it didn’t bother me how Betsy and Tacy were trying to match-make for her. Having your best friends try to find you a partner – you could do worse! Though they didn’t exactly nail it.

Kathleen: Yes, I love it! They are terrible at it!

Theresa: Betsy and Tacy always need to have a project.

Joe and Harry laughed at the Bagshaw plots but are genuinely concerned about Rocky. What are they worried about?

Kathleen: He’s a love ’em and leave ’em kinda guy. I know Tib can handle herself, but she’s so tiny! Joe is probably feeling protective.

Rita: Rocky has been around, and Tib is somewhat naïve. And this is an example of Maud’s tact. We know that he wants to have sex with her, but Maud doesn’t say so explicitly.

Marlena: Some men can simply see other men for who they are.

Melody: The dead giveaway that he’s bad news is that he rained on her parade constantly. He doesn’t like to dance, so Tib never dances.

Rita: Later, she says that Joe respects Betsy as a person, and it’s clear that Rocky obviously does not show this to Tib.

Marlena: I like that Tib goes home after the Rocky situation.

Before Rocky, have we really had an example of a bad relationship?

Kathleen: Don and Emily. Julia and Mr. Gaston.

Kristen: Revenge for the rosy apple blossoms?!

Amaree: I’d say Betsy and Tony because that relationship isn’t founded on honesty. As much as we love Tony, it’s a mistake from the beginning, and she isn’t able to honest with him until it reaches a crisis

Jen: Such a good point! There are so many ways to be a bad relationship, and it doesn’t mean that the people in it are bad.

Do you think Tib was unkind to Mr. Bagshaw? Do you think the Crowd is a little unkind to him?

Jen: For the first time, this story didn’t sit well with me. It felt to me like they were always making fun of him and laughing at him behind his back.

Rita: I don’t care about him, so I don’t care how they treat him.

Kristen: Same. I found him materialistic and unappealing.

Paula: I think Mr. Bagshaw was too old for Tib and should have known better.

Theresa: How old was he supposed to be? He looks ancient in the book!

Marlena: He was pretty generous.

Paula: Generosity can be used to control.

The pace of Tib and Jack’s romance is quite breathless! What are the signs that Jack is the right guy for her?

Sonja: So many marriages happened quickly at the beginning of the war. I was very relieved when the Companion came out and I learned that not everyone had died, as I had feared.

Rita: Jack understood her. He gave her a sewing machine for a wedding present!

Marlena: I always wondered if George Lucas had read this book because of Tib saying “I am not the blonde you’re looking for”?

Off to War

Some people dislike how “cavalier” Betsy seems about the war. How would you respond to that?

Sonja: It bothers me that we don’t see more of her corresponding with and worried about all the friends she made in Europe.

Rita: She thinks about Hanni, who isn’t going to get to marry her soldier, and she wonders what will happen to all her friends. And also there’s a focus on Tib and how the impending war affects a German American.

Jen: Yes, I was interested that Betsy thinks of Hanni – and also Helena, though she doesn’t mention her name – but not Maida when “Canadian troops were stricken.”

Why might Maud have chosen to not make her concerns more overt in this book?

Rita: Betsy had other things to think about!

Jen: Ha, exactly. This book is about Betsy and Joe learning to make a life together, and that is the focus. And I always wonder about the editor/publisher who kept telling Maud not to include so many characters.

Love and Marriage

In real life, everyone but Midge (and Kathleen) stays married to their first partner. What evidence do you see that these are lifelong happy marriages?

Maddi: We know these characters so well, and we love seeing how perfectly their spouses fit with their personalities. We believe they’re going to be happy.

Jen: When Tacy is worried about Tib and Rocky, she says, “What do they have in common? Are they congenial? Do they like to do the same things?” Clearly this is what she thinks is important in a marriage, and the implication is that this is true for her and Harry. I love that.

Rita: Successful marriages are when the two have honest and realistic views of each other.

Diane: SO TRUE!

Paula: It seems to me that Married Betsy has a more limited life than the Betsy I loved throughout the series. She now has to work around Joe’s moods, his needs. I do think it was a very egalitarian marriage, but his schedule is always going to take precedence.

Meghan Sweeney posits that Maud is in a precarious position with this book, as “marriage represents the end of the titillating romantic tension that has sustained much of the series.” Does Maud find other ways to sustain tension and to bring in drama and conflict?

Melody: I love this book because this was the time when my grandmother was living. I had never thought about the conflict of cars, horses, and wagons all on the streets at the same time! There are HUGE changes happening – telephones! One of my favorite parts was when Mr. Ray finally buys a car – and no one in the house can or will drive it. I laughed and laughed!

Theresa: There’s definitely the Aunt Ruth tension because that brings about such change for Betsy and Joe on many levels. And then there’s the underlying tension of Betsy’s growth into being part of a couple, a married woman, and how her writing fits into that.

That Ending and “Betsy’s Bettina”

Is this chapter a good ending for both this book and the entire series? Look how much Maud packs into that final chapter. A walk on the Big Hill with Tacy, gathering wildflowers!

Susan: Yes!

Did you know? Maud had to describe her wedding dress to Vera Neville because no pictures exist and the dress was later destroyed in a fire. Kelly Reuter, a founding BTS Board member, is a talented seamstress; she followed every clue in the writing and illustration and created a copy, which her daughter Allegra wore at the 2009 Betsy-Tacy Convention.

Attendee Susan Wagenhals shared the 1911 wedding portrait of her grandmother, Alma Sawyer Wagenhals, whose wedding dress Susan has famously worn at two Conventions. Says Susan, “Grandma Wagenhals was six years older than Maud. The black sash around the waist is part of the original dress ensemble. In 2007, my mom found it inside an old manila envelope marked ‘wedding sash’ in Grandma’s handwriting.”

 “Closing words:

(from Sweeney, 2007) While many readers would have loved to see another Betsy book, Lovelace’s ending was apt and she knew it. If she had tried to prolong the series, all the productive possibilities the weddings put into play would be sealed off. By ending in a space where past and future, self and other meld (in what Betsy calls “the land of dreams”), Lovelace avoids a fixed ending. Now, not only can readers turn back, in cyclical fashion, to the beginning of the series, we can, happily, imagine a whole host of ever-afters for Betsy, for Tacy, and for Tib.

(from Goodreads) For once I’m glad Tony was never heard from again after departing from Deep Valley in Betsy and Joe. I don’t have to picture him in the trenches. I’m going to leave this series with Joe and Betsy dancing on the porch during Tib’s wedding.

Sonja asked if this were the last international discussion, since we’ve now gone through the whole series. No! I adores these, and we will start all over again with Betsy-Tacy in January. If anyone would like to cohost with me, please let me know! You can sign up for all the book discussions in our Shop:

https://shop.betsy-tacysociety.org/shop/events/12

Please join us!