News

Betsy Was a Junior Discussion, Part 2 Recap

In September, for part 1 of our discussion of this book, we talked about Betsy “taking stock” – and conveniently omitting, as Rita noted, what JOE might want; how different Margaret is from her sisters and why Maud might have done this deliberately as a writer (rather exactly how counterpart Helen was in real life); what drew Joe and Phyllis to each other and whether we think they were spoony – a thought that inspired much horror/laughter among those assembled.

Host Elle Rupert had some wonderful topics for tonight as well! She did literally all the heavy lifting, as I – your usual host Jen D-K – sat back and embroidered my jabot, just as gorgeously as Betsy would have.

Margaret’s Party for the Pets

I know this is many people’s least favorite moments in the series. If it’s yours, why? If you don’t hate it so much, what do you like, or even appreciate, about this scene?

Nancy Mohlis: When I first read it I was horrified. We had a gas stove when I was a kid, and it always scared me. But I like how Betsy redeems herself in this chapter. And I think it was brave of Maud to portray herself in not such a favorable light.

Carla: It’s a great way to have your main character take an assessment and realize, “I have got to grow up!”

Stephanie: In this chapter, we see Betsy realize what’s actually important to her

Do we actually see any evidence that Betsy does a better job of being present for Margaret after this incident?

Jen: Margaret is there for every meeting of the Decoration Committee for the Junior-Senior Banquet! And I’m in the minority here; I don’t think a teenager is beholden to include her 10-year-old sister in everything. But Betsy does include her from then on.

Janet: Margaret is older than her age, in terms of who she’s interested in. She’s very different from her sisters

Linda: My sister is six years younger, and she was a pain in the neck when I was growing up!

Do you think Margaret would have been allowed to be home alone for hours at her age? This feels like one of the most egregious parts – not just that Betsy is minimizing the party, but also that Margaret would be home alone for hours at all, party or not. 

Kate S: You know, Betsy is only 16. The illustrations make the girls seem older. We need to give poor Betsy a break here!

Jennifer: They seemed 25 to me when I first read these books

Theresa: BT&T were cooking on the stove at age 8, because of Tib

Stephanie: I was a bad, untrustworthy kid who was left alone all the time 🤣

Diane: I actually hired an 11-year-old babysitter 35 years ago. Kind of horrifies me now!

In the Companion, we learn that Helen had an incident that burned her eyelashes, but it wasn’t because of a party and Maud wasn’t supposed to be there when it happened. Why did Maud include this incident happening to Margaret even though it didn’t correlate to real life?

Mary H: It’s very dramatic! Margaret’s eyelashes are one of people’s favorite things about her. It really pulls us in.

Rita: The point isn’t what happened to Margaret – it’s what happened to Betsy. It is suddenly borne on her that she is not a good big sister. This is part of her growing up and realizing that her choices affect other people.

Kathy: And it fits in with the whole story about Betsy being preoccupied with frivolous things, getting lost in more trivial stuff – which has consequences!

College and Sororities

Mr. Ray has a lot of concerns about sororities, and his concerns come to be reality, but he doesn’t stop either of his daughters from going down this path. What do you think that says about his parenting style?

Theresa: It says that he’s a great dad! Just like in Heaven when he says “Doing something because of what other people will think of it is the poorest reason ever” – such a good message for kids. It’s so hard to let our kids learn from their own mistakes!

Rita: Mr. Ray leaves it to them to figure it out

Dawn: It’s completely consistent with his (and Mrs. Ray’s) parenting style. But I also love to watch their struggles as parents, seeing Julia in so much pain but deciding not to “rescue” her.

Carla: And Betsy helped with that – she told the Rays that Julia had a true breakthrough in church

Should someone like Miss Clarke have given Betsy a heads-up earlier as to where things were headed so Betsy had the opportunity to fix things earlier? It seems like the teachers are quite close with the Crowd, and yet they don’t provide any guidance until things have gone too far.

Stephanie: I think the teachers were being like Mr. Ray, seeing this as an opportunity for Betsy to make a mature decision on her own

Meg: I got the feeling that Miss Clarke is as upset as Betsy is, and I wonder if it really wasn’t her choice – if it was actually Miss Bangeter’s decision

Margaret: It’s another instance of Betsy seeing a negative consequence for what she’s doing

Theresa: Maybe the sorority was the instigator for the educators to say, “You know, maybe we should give some other kids a chance.” Betsy’s Crowd was really the “in” crowd, and on this reread I wondered for the first time if I would’ve liked them if I’d been at Deep Valley High and wasn’t part of that group?

Diane: I’m know I’m obsessed with the Essay Contest, but I think this decision is inherently unfair because no one even gave them a heads up. There was no warning, no opportunity to change their behavior. If she had any inkling that she might lose the Essay Contest, I believe Betsy would have dropped the sorority.

Jennifer: This is made up, by the way – Deep Valley history was NOT the topic Maud’s junior year. MAUD CHOSE IT TO HURT US !!!!!!

Elle: Maybe Betsy could have anticipated the decision since she hadn’t won the past two years, but she’s told pretty clearly both that she didn’t win and the kids aren’t liking her so much right now . . . so because of both those things she’s not going to get a chance this year

Jennifer: OMG, I am going to quote this for the rest of my life: “You didn’t win AND the kids don’t really like you!” 🤣

Carla: I feel sorry for Carney. It was her senior year, and she lost out on things she was expecting to do

Mary H: Betsy is more cavalier with some of her choices because she doesn’t have Joe. It’s all Joe’s fault!

Stephanie: JOE GOING TO CLARKE TO APPEAL BETSY’S CASE! 😭😍

Mr. Ray and Julia

We are told why Mr. Ray is worried about Julia pursuing music – it’s a tough job, and he’s not certain it’s realistic. But why is he so set on her attending the U? On page 174 in my edition, he says that he hopes her voice will be used for lullabies. He doesn’t expect her to get a career out of her college experience, so why do you imagine he thought the U was so crucial to her experience?

Cindy: Rereading this time, I realized Mr. Ray sent Julia to the U to find a husband!

Jennifer: We see it over and over: He’s a wonderful dad but he does not “get” his daughters the way his wife does. But that also makes his support of their baffling careers all the more fabulous

Carla: It’s one of the things I adore about the Rays: They want their daughters to marry and have children, but they also SUPPORT each one with her dreams

Elle: Betsy’s trunk!!

Stephanie: Except for the Queen of Summer fiasco!

Lindsey: It’s really good for Julia’s character growth not to get something she wants – possibly for the first time!

The Typhoid Outbreak of 1908

The Companion says that Dennie’s father and many others died from the typhoid outbreak, including Tom Slade’s mother and Tony’s brother. Irma and her parents, Tacy’s father, and Carney’s father were all sick but survived. Maud chooses to leave in other difficult things happening in the world in her books, but she left out the typhoid outbreak. Why do you think she chose not to include it?

Mary H: She also doesn’t mention the Titanic going down! I think she sometimes leaves out major calamities on purpose.

Kate: I’ve wondered what the Ray parents think about sending their daughters on transatlantic trips post-Titanic!

Carla: Especially with the Columbic being from the same shipping company!

Kathy: I think it’s connected with Cab’s father dying. She couldn’t put in all the people who died, so she chose Cab’s father to represent all the people and the impact it had on the Crowd – especially Betsy.

Jennifer: And as much as we like Dennie, we LOVE Cab and so does Betsy. It hits a lot harder

Theresa: Maybe Maud left out a lot of these topics because of the young audience she was writing for and wanting to have a certain tone to her books

Meg: Yes, from a storytelling perspective, making the actual history part of the book would have given it a completely different tone – it would have had to be a different book, plot, etc.

Activity: Taking Stock 

During Part 1, Elle posed a fun challenge: “Take stock” as Betsy does by making resolutions for home, work or hobby, and romance. We could do this as ourselves in real life, as an actual character in the BT universe, or as a new character inserted into Betsy’s world. Elle put together a delightful slideshow of people’s responses, for example:

Said Elle, “Here was a surprise: Two people chose to be Irma . . . and Miss Biscay caught quite a bit of shade!”

OH, did we laugh at this!

Stephanie: LOL . . . Red Feather comment!!!

Diane: I had a friend who was an Irma in high school. Irresistible to boys and very flirtatious. She was also a very fun friend to her girlfriends, we were jealous but also loved her. She grew up to be a very accomplished woman, no longer flirtatious and does not steal anyone’s husband or boyfriend as an adult 😆 and we are still good friends all these years later.

Carla: Irma is a good, thoughtful girl!

Theresa: She was just the most developed

Stephanie: Hey, when you’ve got it, you’ve got it. SHINE ON, IRMA

As the closing hour drew near, many of us noted that the two discussions – and Elle’s questions, in particular – made us more deeply appreciate Junior.

Carla: I think rereading for discussion, and the depth of these discussions, truly make us reassess the books

Janet: Elle, you really helped me think more deeply about this book and appreciate its importance. It had been my least favorite but on this reread I realized that all the things that annoyed me are getting resolved, and Maud really shows us Betsy’s growth as a person.

Elle’s closing words:

As I mentioned previously, BWAJ is probably my favorite book of the series, although it’s hard to choose a favorite. I love seeing Tib back, reading about all the parties and highjinks is so much fun and this book has the most scenes I would like to re-create in my own life. As a former high school educator, I think the sorority, friend dynamics, and natural consequences that Betsy faces are all very realistic and in many ways satisfying. And the scene where Julia discovers she’ll be going to Europe! There’s nothing like it!

I will close with a review I found on Goodreads that I liked a lot:

With every book the characters from this series become dearer and dearer to me. I really enjoyed the growth we see from Betsy in this books. The final chapter, in particular, struck a chord with me as Betsy confronted the inescapable reality that she and her fellow members of “The Crowd” are growing up. However, my absolute favorite part of this series is the slow burn relationship that is building between Betsy and Joe. Their interactions, carefully sprinkled throughout the book, is what made me devour every page any spare second that I had. From the moment they met during the summer before high school, their connection has been undeniable, fueled by their shared love for books and writing. The building anticipation of their relationship is making me anxious to start the next book, titled Betsy and Joe (FINALLY!!!!)

As always, the side chat comprised many fun topics, including the appeal (or not) of Strong Silent Dave (“the guy who just randomly shows up at your house,” according to Lindsey), Mallory’s flattering lighting, how many people were in Betsy’s graduating class (there were 41 in Maud’s), which BT book is the most dated, what Omega Delta could possibly stand for, sorority recruitment (aka “rush”) being stressful even if you know you’re getting in, the MISGUIDED PERSON on StoryGraph who can’t tell the difference between Cab and Dennie, and Mary G’s grandmother’s herbarium – which doesn’t include a single fall flower!!

It was a perfectly grand discussion, and we all had a wonderful time.

Next up:

  • November 14: Betsy’s Wedding discussion – International edition!
  • November 15: Betsy and Joe discussion, part 1

Sign up for all events here: https://shop.betsy-tacysociety.org/shop/events/12

Please join us!